Open now 274 N Keswick Ave, Glenside PA · (215) 886-9900 Order direct — no third-party fees
Pizza Blog

The Evolution of the Cheesesteak: How One Sandwich Conquered American Food Culture

The Evolution of the Cheesesteak: How One Sandwich Conquered American Food Culture

Cheesesteaks began as a quick lunch cooked on a hot dog cart’s flat top in South Philadelphia around 1930, and within a single century the sandwich spread to diners, pizza shops, stadiums and food trucks in every state. Today, whether you are picking up a classic steak at Pat’s or placing an order at Glenside Pizza, the core recipe remains largely unchanged: thinly sliced ribeye steak, a long roll, melted cheese, and onions if you want them. What changed was who was making it and who was eating it.

The story of how that happened says a lot about American food in general, because the cheesesteak is one of the few regional sandwiches that managed to go national without losing its hometown identity.

A Hot Dog Cart, a Flat Top, and 1930s South Philadelphia

The widely repeated origin story credits Pat Olivieri, a hot dog vendor near the Italian Market who grilled beef for his own lunch and sold a version of it to a cab driver who smelled it cooking. The stand that grew out of that lunch, Pat’s King of Steaks, still sits at the corner of 9th and Passyunk and still runs 24 hours a day.

The first versions had no cheese at all. They were chopped beef and onions on an Italian roll, closer to a steak sandwich than what people order today. That matters, because the cheese arrived later and from a different part of the neighborhood entirely.

Joe Lorenza, a manager at Pat’s, is generally credited with adding provolone in the 1940s. Cheez Whiz, the ingredient most tourists associate with an authentic Philly cheesesteak, did not exist until 1952 and did not become standard until years after that.

The Three Cheeses and Why the Argument Never Ends

Ask ten people in Philly what belongs on the sandwich and you will get provolone, American and Whiz in some order of preference, usually with strong feelings attached. Provolone brings sharpness and a little funk. American melts into the meat more evenly and is what most South Philly natives actually order.

Whiz gets the headlines because it photographs well and because politicians keep ordering it on camera. Locals tend to treat it as the tourist option, though plenty of lifelong residents genuinely prefer it for the way it coats every strand of beef.

The cheese debate survives because there is no governing body and no official recipe. A sandwich defined by three ingredients leaves exactly enough room for people to argue about one of them forever.

The Lingo That Turned an Order Into a Ritual

At the older South Philly windows, the expected order is cheese first, onions second: “Whiz wit” means Cheez Whiz with onions, and “provolone witout” means exactly what it sounds like. Step up and read the board for too long and the line behind you makes its feelings known.

That shorthand is part of why the sandwich became a cultural export rather than just a local lunch. It gave visitors something to learn, repeat and brag about later, which is the same mechanism that turned New York bagels and Chicago deep dish into travel destinations.

Outside Philadelphia the lingo relaxes. Most neighborhood spots, including the counter at Glenside Pizza, will happily take a full sentence, and nobody loses their place in line for asking what comes on it. 

Why the Sandwich Traveled Better Than Most Regional Foods

Plenty of regional specialties stay regional because they need equipment, ingredients or technique that does not exist elsewhere. Cheesesteaks had the opposite problem: almost every corner shop in America already owned the gear.

  • The flat-top griddle was already standard in diners, pizzerias, luncheonettes and bar kitchens.
  • Frozen sliced ribeye became widely available through foodservice distributors in the 1970s and 1980s, which removed the skill barrier.
  • The roll was the one real constraint, and bakeries along the East Coast solved it by shipping par-baked loaves regionally.
  • Ticket time runs about four to six minutes, which fits the rhythm of a lunch rush anywhere.

Pizza shops turned out to be the ideal carrier. They already had the oven for toasting rolls, the mozzarella and provolone on hand, and a delivery system looking for more items to sell. That is how the sandwich reached towns that never sent anyone to Philadelphia, including the neighborhood shops that now anchor dinner in Glenside for families on a weeknight.

Regional Variants You Will Not Find at 9th and Passyunk

Once the sandwich left the city, local kitchens started editing it. Some of those edits are now older than many of the people arguing about authenticity.

  • The pizza steak: marinara and mozzarella instead of Whiz, common across the Philadelphia suburbs and the Lehigh Valley.
  • The chicken cheesesteak: an early 1980s addition that now outsells beef at some shops, especially with broccoli rabe or long hots.
  • Jersey Shore style: heavier on sauteed peppers and mushrooms, often served on a seeded roll from a local bakery.
  • The Brick and Ocean County versions: frequently built with American cheese and sold year-round in towns that triple in population every July.
  • The West Coast interpretation: grilled onions, bell peppers and mayo, which Philadelphians consider a different sandwich wearing a borrowed name.

Each variant reflects whatever that region already had in its walk-in. The sandwich adapted because its structure, hot meat and melted cheese in a soft roll, tolerates almost any addition.

What Separates a Great One From a Forgettable One

The best cheesesteaks are decided at the griddle and at the bakery, not by the cheese choice. Meat sliced too thick turns chewy, and meat held too long on the flat top dries into gravel.

The roll carries more weight than people expect. It needs a crust with enough structure to hold a half pound of meat and juice without disintegrating, plus a soft interior that compresses when you bite. Philadelphia shops have relied on Amoroso’s and Liscio’s for generations for exactly that reason.

Onions should be cooked down until they are soft and sweet, roughly eight to ten minutes on a moderate griddle, then chopped into the meat rather than piled on top. When a shop is feeding a crowd, that same assembly scales cleanly, which is why trays of steaks show up so often at parties and office lunches alongside catering in Abington orders.

Making a Philly Cheesesteak Recipe Work at Home

A home cheesesteak recipe fails for one of two reasons: the pan is not hot enough, or the steak is not cold enough to slice thin. Freeze a ribeye for 45 to 60 minutes, then cut against the grain as thinly as your knife allows, somewhere near an eighth of an inch.

Use cast iron over the highest heat your range produces, cook the onions first, then add the beef in a single layer and chop it with two spatulas as it browns. Lay the cheese directly on the pile, let it melt for 30 seconds, then scoop the whole thing into the roll in one motion.

Taste the Version Your Neighborhood Shop Has Been Perfecting

The sandwich has had almost a hundred years of local interpretation, and the best way to understand it is to eat one made by people who make hundreds a week. If you have questions about our steaks or want to put in an order for a crowd, contact Glenside Pizza today.

Hungry yet?

Order direct for pickup or delivery — no third-party fees.

More from the blog